The new and final season of Lost promised to answer many lingering questions, too many questions to list here, however the first episode probably left me with more questions. This confounding but brilliant series has thrown so many twists at us that at times it's hard to remember all the things we need to know this year. But they've sure gotten off to a typical start. Meaning: "What????"
I'm in Ottawa right now, on a 20 minute time limit for my usage (by the way, never stay at the Travel Lodge), so I'm mostly going to summarize the main points from the episode (entitled "LA X").
What we're faced with over the two-hour episode is what appears to be two realities. In one reality, we have our beloved survivors on that fateful plane from Australia on their way back to LAX... and it doesn't crash! But during the flight, we already see glimpses of how, perhaps, their experience on the island was positive for them. In particular, for Kate and Charlie.
In the other reality, they are catapulted back into the "present day" (which in the Lost world is now 2007), on the island, and believe they have failed. Juliet, however, contends that they succeeded with her dying breath. Weird.
So, again: "WHAT?" At least, that's how I felt after the first 10 minutes.
Now, the two realities go back and forth repeatedly throughout the two hours, but I'll just summarize both separately...
Reality 1 (LAX trip). What's most important here is:
So, I think that's all the main points. Now, I'm really at a loss here. So, there are two realities here that are obviously in opposition to each other. So, which one is real? Are they both? How? Is one a kind of purgatory, like people have thought all along? They both can't be real because the island is at the bottom of the ocean in the first reality. When the episode ended, I scratched my head and thought: "Cool" because it was. But then I got a headache. It seems like they have a LOT of work to do to resolve all the questions they promised they'd answer. I'm not convinced they will. One thing is certain, however: this season is going to be one heck of a ride. Let's see where it goes.
What are everybody's thoughts/suspicions/theories?
Well there is always the chance that the "other reality" is a flash forward of some sort and at the end of the series they find a way to reset things. But also we have the mystery of what exactly Jacob and the smoke monster are and that could tie in as well. Let's say that the bomb did create an alternate reality... could it be that now the group of Jack, Sawyer, Kate, etc. are now in a similar predicament to Jacob in that maybe these alternate versions of themselves are now trapped on the island or have to stay there forever in exchange for the rest of the passengers to get to go home?
Also... dead people have been appearing to people on the show for quite some time. We now see that the smoke monster can take on the form of someone who has died... could Jacob do so as well? And if he couldn't... all those times they've seen ghosts of people, has that been the smoke monster?
I think before we get any solid theories together we'll need a few more questions answered. There's waaaaay too much leeway for "what if's" still.
Paul Little says...
Cindy (the stewardess) has shown up a few times on the island post-crash, as she (and the 2 children whose names escape me) were kidnapped by the Others from the camp of the Tailies, and obviously "converted" at some point after that.
The temple has been mentioned several times in the past, but it's interesting to finally see the Others who live there. They seem to be a lot different than the Others who were travelling with Richard, Ben, and FakeLocke. I'm sure we'll find out a lot as time goes on.
I'm very curious about the relationship between the Others and the Smoke Monster. First, can ONLY the "Man in Black" (Jacob's nemesis from last season's finale) become him, or can Jacob too? If it's only the MiB, why did it appear that sometimes ol' Smokey was helping out the Others in the past (like when Ben called for it to come out and take care of the evil Freighties who had just killed his daughter)? Assuming the Others worship/follow Jacob, why would Jacob's enemy sometimes help them?
The "flash sideways" stuff going on (that's what Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse, the show's creators, have been referring to the "crash never happened" timeline as) is very intriguing. I like how things aren't exactly the same. Shannon didn't get on the flight, Michael and Walt aren't there, Desmond is somehow on the flight, Hurley actually feels LUCKY, Christian's coffin didn't make it on the plane, Locke MAY have actually gone on the walkabout -- even the fact that Jack was afraid of the turbulance and Rose wasn't. And of course, THE ISLAND IS UNDER WATER! There are changes in the timeline that I'm sure we'll learn more about. But it's interesting to see these characters interact and still be so intertwined even without the crash on the island.
I guess I was a little underwhelmed with the season opener not because it was "bad", but because for the first time in a LONG time with this series, I pretty much had everything pegged before it happened (due to my own assumptions, or taking on other people's theories). I was almost certain that MiB was the same as the Smoke Monster, and that he had taken the form of Locke. (It seems I may not turn out to be right on my second part of that theory, though, that Locke is too important to things and somehow isn't completely dead.) I was also almost certain that the season would follow 2 storylines: one as if the plan to reset time didn't work, and one where the crash never happened (though I didn't expect the changes). I like Lost for its "HOLY CRAP!" moments, and I guess personally I didn't get any in that first episode, though I'm sure I'll get a ton going forward.
I'm just confused.... but hooked, of course. Maybe I can see things more clearly in the next episode???!!!
i definatly think the "man in black" is the smoke monster. Does anyone else think that maybe Sayid is now Jacob??
Paul Little says...
It seems like Jacob took over Sayid. Maybe the Man in Black can appear AS someone who's dead, while Jacob can take over a dead body -- so while the Man in Black might have been Eko's brother, it's possible that Jacob has been Christian this whole time (since nobody ever found his body)?
Upon first watching it I thought Jacob took over Sayid untill later that night Cruse and Linsdorf were on Jimmy Kimmel and after listening to them I dont think that is what happen